Toby's Tavern boasts a diverse menu that features everything from comforting bar bites to hearty soul food. Standouts include the fried chicken, loaded with flavor and often served alongside yams—both a beloved local specialty. The wings come in various flavors, including garlic parmesan and lemon pepper, delighting many taste buds. For casual dining, mouthwatering burgers and sandwiches are available, as well as lighter fare like salads. A simple yet satisfying selection of desserts, like peach cobbler and pound cake, rounds off the meal. The drink menu shines with a great assortment of beers, cocktails, and wines, enhancing late-night dining or brunch with friends. Happy-hour specials often tempt patrons with quality food and drinks at a great value.